Decision details

Sheltered Housing Digital Alarm Upgrade

Decision Maker: Assistant Director - Housing

Decision status: Recommendations Approved

Is Key decision?: Yes

Is subject to call in?: Yes

Purpose:

Upgrading of the sheltered housing hard wired pull cord system from an analogue to a digital system.

Decision:

That the Council awards a contract to Tunstall Healthcare Ltd for a fully managed Sheltered Housing Digital Equipment upgrade with an on-going maintenance, repair and monitoring service for an initial period of 5 years with the option for an extension for up to an additional 5 years. The contract values include capital investment of £603,993 for upgrading the equipment and an on-going service chargeable annual contract of £116,907 for maintenance, repair, and monitoring.

Reasons for the decision:

Following an open tender process (which is fully compliant with UK procurement and the Council’s Contract Procedural rules). The returned tender was scored independently by three officers in accordance with the evaluation criteria set out in the documents provided to the bidding organisations (30% price, 70% quality). The tender prices were scrutinised using soft market testing data to ensure prices were competitive.

 

Following the tender process, the tender submitted by Tunstall Healthcare Ltd was considered to meet all the Council’s requirements to meet current and future tenants needs.

Alternative options considered:

Option 1 – Do nothing. This is not considered a viable option as the digital transition will result in life critical equipment in tenant’s properties ceasing to work. Option not recommended.

 

Option 2 – Remove all the equipment. We consulted with our tenants on their views about the equipment and the usage that the system had. Most tenants responding to the survey voted for the equipment to remain with an average of over 2000 calls each month. Option not recommended.

Interests and Nature of Interests Declared:

None.

Reason Key: Incurring expenditure above £75,000 threshold in respect of revenue/£180,000 in respect of capital;

Wards Affected: (All Wards);

Conflict of Interest: None

Dispensation Granted: None

Other reasons / organisations consulted

Formal and informal

Consultees

Tenants; Portfolio Holder and informal all member briefing

Contact: Beverley Chapman, Tenant Engagement and Influence Lead Email: Beverley.Chapman@sholland.gov.uk, Jason King, Executive Director - Communities Email: JasonKing@sholland.gov.uk.

Publication date: 14/12/2023

Date of decision: 14/12/2023

Effective from: 22/12/2023

Accompanying Documents: