Consideration was given to the report of the
Service Director – Corporate Services which ask members to
consider an approach to future strategy/policy review and
development in the lead up to Local Government
Reorganisation(LGR).
The Service Director – Corporate
Services was in attendance virtually to introduce the report and
explained that in light of LGR and increasing organisational
pressures, a review had been undertaken of the current approach to
policy review cycles. It was proposed that, where policies did not
require material changes, the review dates could be extended to
March 2028, with minor amendments being delegated to the relevant
Service Director and Portfolio Holder.
Members considered the report and made the
following comments:
- Members expressed concern that the
proposed delegation arrangements could reduce the role of the Panel
in scrutinising policy changes and emphasised the importance of maintaining the
Panel’s ability to review and challenge policies. Whilst
members supported efficiency saving, scrutiny should not be
diminished as a result.
- The Service Director –
Corporate Services clarified that members would retain the ability
to call in any policy at any time and that substantive changes
would still be brought to the Panel and Cabinet for consideration,
ensuring that scrutiny powers were maintained.
- Members highlighted that by
providing delegated authority solely to Service Directors and
Portfolio Holders it could give the perception that policies were
being agreed without appropriate scrutiny.
- The Service Director –
Corporate Services suggested that delegation could be exercised in
consultation with the Chairman of the Panel, providing an
additional safeguard and enabling members to request that any
changes be brought forward for formal scrutiny.
- Members acknowledged that where no
material changes were required, it was reasonable to avoid bringing
policies back to the panel unnecessarily and this reflected the
Panel’s existing approach.
- Members emphasised that the Panel
should be notified of any policy changes, including minor or
legislative amendments, and suggested that details of amendments
could be circulated electronically to members in advance.
- The Service Director –
Corporate Services advised that whilst delegation of minor
amendments formed part of the proposed efficiency measures,
concerns regarding oversight and accountability were acknowledged,
and therefore suggested that a system of notification could be
implemented, whereby members would be informed of proposed
amendments in advance. This approach would give members the opportunity to request that a
policy be called in for further consideration, ensuring both
transparency and efficiency within the revised process.
- Members agreed that they should be
given the opportunity to “call in” policies for
scrutiny where concerns were identified and that this approach
would allow efficiency savings whilst retaining appropriate
oversight.
·
In conclusion, members supported the revised approach, provided the
following safeguards were in place to ensure transparency and
continued member oversight:
o
Policy review dates could be extended where only minor,
non-material changes were required;
o
Delegation of minor amendments to the relevant Service Director and
Portfolio Holder were supported in principle however, subject to
members being notified in advance and provided with an opportunity
to request further scrutiny; and
o
Amendments needed to be clearly highlighted and that details of the
deadline for member responses should be included when circulating
changes.
AGREED:
That the feedback of the Policy Development
Panel be noted to inform a future decision.