Consideration was given to the report of the
Executive Director – Communities which provided an update on
the current performance of the garden waste collection.
The Executive Director – Communities
introduced the report which provided an interim update following
the implementation of revised garden waste collection rounds,and the following main points were
highlighted:
- Concerns had been raised regarding
the accuracy of collection information and the accessibility of
reporting systems, affecting approximately 2,500 garden waste
subscribers;
- The report outlined the challenges
encountered during implementation, the actions taken to address
these issues, and the current position of the service. It was
confirmed that, following initial difficulties, the revised
collection rounds were now operating effectively and had enabled
district-wide access to the service.
- Work was ongoing to establish the
root causes of the issues experienced, including the commissioning
of an independent review, with a view to identifying lessons
learned and ensuring these were applied to future service changes.
A more detailed report on the findings of the review would be
presented to a future meeting.
Members considered the report and made the
following comments:
- Members noted that similar systems
had been in use by the Council for many years and expressed
concerned of the issues caused on this occasion, requesting a
deeper understanding of the reasons and causes.
- The Executive Director –
Communities responded that:
- In terms of day-to-day operations,
the core system, including the in-cab Bartec technology, was operating effectively, and
collections were now functioning as intended following resolution
of the initial issues;
- Problems had arisen as a result of
system configuration changes made in conjunction with IT to
introduce revised collection rounds. The original system had been
designed for a more limited garden waste scheme, and when new
rounds were introduced, this effectively overlaid new data onto the
existing configuration. This resulted in conflicting information
within the system, which caused the issues experienced. It was
acknowledged that the issue should have been identified during
system testing prior to implementation, and understanding why this
was not detected would form a key element of the independent
review;
- Assurance was given that the
configuration approach used in this instance would not be
replicated and future rounds would instead be developed using the
Routeware system, which is used by
other authorities, with routes then integrated directly into the
Bartec system. This approach was
expected to provide a more robust solution. In conclusion, the
issue was attributed to the way in which changes had been applied
to the system, rather than a failure of the core operational
technology.
- Members expressed disappointment
that issues had occurred following a significant lead-in period for
implementation.
- The Executive Director –
Communities acknowledged this concern and accepted that the outcome
had not met expectations. It was confirmed that lessons learned,
including system configuration and testing processes, would be
incorporated into future service changes.
- Members queried whether the system
would be capable of managing different collection methods,
including both bins and bags, and identifying property-level
requirements.
- The Executive Director –
Communities confirmed that the system would hold property-level
data, including collection requirements, and would support service
delivery across different collection methods.
- Members raised concerns regarding
the clarity, consistency, and accuracy of communications issued to
residents, stating the following issues: conflicting information
within correspondence, inconsistencies regarding subscription
extensions and expiry dates, lack of clarity regarding ownership of
garden waste bins and collection arrangements, and a data breach
where email correspondence had been incorrectly circulated to
multiple recipients. There was a need to ensure communications
relating to future waste service changes were clear and consistent.
- The Executive Director –
Communities agreed that a review of communications would be
beneficial and confirmed that an end-to-end review of all related
communications would be included as part of the wider
investigation. This would aim to ensure that future communications
were clear, accurate, and consistent across all channels. The data
breach matter had been investigated and reported appropriately,
including referral to the Information Commissioner’s Office.
Internal actions had been identified and implemented to prevent
recurrence.
- Members queried whether operational
staff knowledge would be incorporated into future route planning.
- The Executive Director –
Communities confirmed that route development would include several
stages, including the use of specialist software and subsequent
review by operational teams to ensure routes were practical and
reflected local knowledge.
- Members noted good collection and
overall service performance figures and requested additional
context to understand the impact of the recent issues. Members
requested comparative performance data for the period 1 April 2026
to 1 May 2026, to be presented alongside the 2025/26 year-end
performance, in order to better illustrate the scale and impact of
the issues experienced following implementation of the revised
rounds.
- The Executive Director –
Communities agreed that comparative data would be useful and
confirmed that this information would be included within the
follow-up report.
- Members raised concerns regarding
how operational challenges, such as road closures, would be managed
under the new arrangements.
- The Executive Director –
Communities advised that operational planning was being developed
and confirmed that further detail would be provided within a future
report.
- Members requested clearer
information in respect of ownership and disposal of garden waste
bins, particularly where residents chose not to renew
subscriptions.
- The Executive Director –
Communities acknowledged that this required further clarification
and agreed to include a detailed explanation of the policy position
within a future report, enabling members to fully understand and
scrutinise the approach.
- Members questioned the approach
taken to compensate residents affected by missed collections,
particularly the provision of additional collections at a later
date when seasonal demand for use may be low.
- The Executive Director –
Communities explained that the intention had been to ensure that
subscribers received the number of collections paid for, with the
additional collections effectively extending the service period and
therefore adjusting the renewal date accordingly.
- Members queried how residents would
be informed of future changes and what role members would play in
supporting communication.
- The Executive Director –
Communities confirmed that further communications and engagement
activity were planned, including a member briefing scheduled for 9
June 2026, which would provide an update on progress, proposals,
and the intended approach to resident engagement. It was
acknowledged that communication materials would need to be clear,
detailed and accessible to ensure members were able to support
residents effectively.
AGREED:
1) That the content of the report be noted; and
2)
The Panel noted that a more detailed report would follow pending
the outcome of a review of what had occurred in relation to the
garden waste collection rounds and any matters requiring
consideration ahead of the wider waste collection round changes
planned for later this year.